We compare Capture One vs. Lightroom on some of the key features that might make a difference to the picky photographer. Do you want to use the best RAW image editor and digital asset manager for your images? We have taken a closer look at two of the best options.
Image editing has been a natural extension to the photography process since the dawn of photography itself. Before entering the digital era, photographers would spend hours developing film in the darkroom, then projecting it on photo paper, hoping they achieved the desired effects.
Although, there are still plenty of people who shoot on film chances are most of us shoot digitally for the most part. Even more so – we depend on editing software to replace the “darkroom” for tweaking our shots after we’re done shooting. Funnily enough, one of the most popular RAW converters out there is Adobe’s Lightroom. And it has been the leading product on the market for years.
What I’ve been noticing recently though, is that more and more colleagues turn to alternatives for their RAW processing and specifically – towards Capture One Pro.
Capture One has been on the market for more than a decade, however, in recent years it catches up to the functionality of Lightroom and I think it’s safe to say that perhaps it is the best competitor of the popular software. Be that as it may, there are still a lot of things to have in mind when deciding which one can suit your needs the best, with some serious pros and cons for Lightroom and Capture One.
In this article I’ll outline the top features that differentiate both applications and how can they boost your workflow. What I’ll leave to you is to weigh the information and hopefully, help you make an informed decision.
- Capture One vs Lightroom
- Cataloging and Digital Asset Management
- Capture One Layers vs. Adjustment Brush in Lightroom
- Color Editing Capabilities: Capture One vs Lightroom
- Lightroom’s HSL Sliders vs. Capture One’s Color Editor Wheels
- Lightroom Is More Popular!
- What About Customization?
- Price Tag: Capture One vs Lightroom
- Why You Might Want to use Lightroom Instead of Capture One?
- Why you would want to switch to Capture One
- Is Capture One Better Than Lightroom?
Capture One vs Lightroom
Cataloging and Digital Asset Management
Aside all the RAW processing power both products offer, a big part of digital asset management is the ability to catalog, filter, rate and sort all your digital images. While objectively good at it, both applications have their own specific way of doing things.
Like Lightroom, Capture One can open files from your hard drive(s) and work on them directly without moving them anywhere, however. Capture One also has a “Session” option, which creates a project like file called a “Session” and a few folders to contain your captures, selects, outputs and trash.
Sessions are typically used for a per-shoot basis like client assignments where you want to sort, select and output the images loaded into the session, without wanting to access them regularly. Catalogs are more designed for containing your entire body of photographic work. In Capture One you can also work with a combination of both sessions and catalogs.
I’d say sessions are pretty neat when shooting tethered, working on a single project or actually working first in a session and then simply importing it in your catalog.
Capture One also features the standard Digital Asset Management (DAM) tools to help you categorize your images in folders, albums, smart albums, searching filters, and keywords. But you can find those pretty much in all organizational software pieces.
Now, when we start talking about exporting from the catalog things get more interesting. They both have what you’d expect – naming files, output location, output sharpening, resolution, quality, etc.
BUT something super useful Capture One has more than Lightroom is the process recipes. It’s not that in Lightroom you can’t make your own export presets and chose them from the menu. However, in Capture One you can select multiple recipes to run at the same time. Yes, It might load a bit more, but it will execute all of the desired output settings in one click of a button. I find that really useful when exporting for different social media channels or providing clients with full-size images for print and images for their social media.
On top of that, there’s the proofing mode which lets you actually see what the exported image is going to look like, so you can take into account things like output sharpening.
While Lightroom gives you a bit more freedom when applying watermarks and/or logos on top of the exports I feel like I had everything I’d need when testing Capture One as well.
Something really clever Capture One is the annotations. They’re pretty much only usable for when somebody else is editing your image, so they can see your guides, but what I was impressed by is that when you export an image with annotations in PSD to be used in Photoshop it exports the annotations in a separate layer which you can toggle on and off in PS.
Capture One Layers vs. Adjustment Brush in Lightroom
And while we’re on the topic of layers… With the release of Capture One Pro 12, Phase One introduced layers which pretty much work as you’d expect – opacity slider, rename option, copying masks between layers, inverting masks and all that. Everything you do is completely nondestructive.
Lightroom has the adjustment points for its gradient, radial masks, and the adjustment brush, but it’s not quite the same. Moreover, now you can apply styles (equal to presets in Lightroom) to layers and tweak the opacity for lower intensity. This is something much requested from Lightroom for years, but for now, it seems like we won’t be getting that luxury.
Something you can do to mimic that effect in Lightroom though is getting Capture Monkey’s plug-in – the Fader. It works in a similar fashion as a layer, but just for presets.
Something else Capture One offers is the creation of masks from selections through the color editor and the use of refine edge tools. Both applications offer gradual filters and with version 12, Capture one introduced radial filter just like the one in Lightroom.
Capture One Pro 12 also introduced the Luma Range tool. This tool really saves you a lot of time, since it allows you to limit your masks to certain luminosity ranges in your image and only work on them. This is a really powerful tool, because it gives you the option to copy those adjustments across all images from the same shoot with similar light conditions, regardless if you subject moved or composition changed!
As I mentioned, Lightroom’s way of things is just different. You paint your adjustments with a filter or a brush. If you want to go back and correct things – you can with the only real downside being that you cannot name the adjustments. It’s only an issue if you have a lot of adjustments.
Color Editing Capabilities: Capture One vs Lightroom
Color has always been a subjective topic when it comes to photography. Adobe is the leader in the image editing and processing software, so their color game is top-notch, but Capture One is developed by Phase One.
Phase One is not just a software company. They are a camera manufacturer company and one that produces top of the range medium format cameras. Basically, Capture One is a software developed by photographers for photographers. And here you can feel the difference already. Capture One uses image color profiles designed for each specific camera model. You can switch between those ICC profiles and the different Curves they offer or choose the Linear Response which is your true RAW file, without any adjustments added by the camera what so ever.
Lightroom’s HSL Sliders vs. Capture One’s Color Editor Wheels
We all know the HSL (Hue, Saturation, Luminosity) tool that Lightroom has for editing colors within your image. It has a few different modes of display and is especially a group of sliders for each of the main colors – Red, Orange, Yellow, Green, Aqua, Blue, Purple, and Magenta. With those sliders, you can adjust the values of these colors changing their intensity, lightness, and hue. Something very useful Lightroom offers is the HSL color picker which allows you to alter colors with directly clicking and dragging on the picture.
Capture One, on the other hand, has the Color Editor, which is more or less the same thing with the main difference being it is visually presented as a color wheel.
The Basic Color Editor offers pre-selected colors to edit just like the HSL but divided into fewer colors. You can choose to edit the Green, Yellow-Orange, Red, Magenta-Purple, Blue, and Aqua. But here comes the advantage of the Color Editor.
In the Advanced tab, you can use the color picker to select the color you wish to edit and narrow it down with smoothness and then change the Hue, Saturation, and Lightness. Moreover, there is an option to make everything else black and white, showing you only what you’ve selected. And if that’s not enough you can actually first paint a mask over the image and edit colors only within the range of that mask.
The third tab of the Color Editor in Capture One is called “Skin Tone” and it is designed to edit, well, skin tone. By selecting the desired skin color in your image you can then use the uniformity slider to make the rest of the skin tones more like the one you’ve selected and then, of course, edit it just like you’d edit any other color. This really helps with removing some colored skin spots and differences in hue on the skin. But the best part is that you can get really creative and actually use the uniformity slider on any other color you wish.
When comparing Capture One vs Lightroom, I dare not say which software is better in editing RAW images, they both have their pros and cons. However, overall Capture One offers more in-depth color editing and finer refinement tools.
Lightroom Is More Popular!
A very big advantage for Lightroom is the popularity of the software, because if you’re one of the people who fancy presets and you don’t mind spending an extra buck on a few – the market is saturated with options. Building up a collection of presets can really speed up your workflow and while Capture One has their equivalent – styles, the feature is still pretty new and not that many options have popped up for sale, yet.
What About Customization?
For better or for worse, when it comes to customization Lightroom has been known to almost not have any option, with very few things you can move around, show or hide. Lightroom looks like it has always looked. Definitely, a perk if, for example, you share your computer with someone else, as everything will always look the same.
Capture One is the opposite. Customizable everything. You can change the default workspaces, put tools anywhere on the screen and even duplicate tools to create new custom tools.
A prime example of that is the curves tool. In Capture One you can duplicate the curves tool twice and have a Red, Green and Blue curve at the same time showing each color separate and with their individual values.
On top of that, you can also change the shortcuts and create your own workflow by changing the default values for each tool you use.
But like I said, if I sit on your computer and open your Capture One I’d probably be lost for a while, because of all the customization decisions you’ve made to suit your flow.
Price Tag: Capture One vs Lightroom
When comparing two products we must definitely pay attention to the price of them as well. Here things get more confusing, however.
In 2017 Adobe created a fork and introduced two versions of the software. One is the same old Lightroom we know, but without a perpetual license now and the other is the Lightroom CC based on creative cloud storage. They are both very much alike and very much different, but that could be a whole article in itself.
The important thing is that you can now only subscribe to the software and depending on what option you want you can choose between:
Lightroom + 1TB cloud for $9.99
Lightroom + Photoshop + 20 GB Cloud for $9.99
Lightroom + Photoshop + 1TB for $19.99
And those are all pretty good prices for what you get, especially when it comes with Photoshop attached.
Capture One can be even more confusing with having perpetual licenses, subscriptions and different versions with support for Sony or Fuji cameras only. Meaning you can get the Pro version with support for all the camera profiles they have or if you shoot only Sony or Fuji – save a few dollars with picking up support only for their camera profiles. Your options here are:
Capture One Pro Perpetual for €349 (no subscription). Approx. $393
Annual monthly plan for €24 (Approx. $27) or €220 (Approx. $247) when prepaid or just monthly for 29 Euro / Aprrox. $33.
Alternatively, the Sony/Fuji versions are:
Perpetual for €249 / Approx. $280. You can find monthly paid plans specifically for Sony/Fuji as well.
Why You Might Want to use Lightroom Instead of Capture One?
Capture One is Expensive
Let’s face it. Capture One is more expensive vs Lightroom, and you don’t even have Photoshop. So you need to weigh if the extra professional tools of Capture One is worth the higher price point. After all, if you are like most photographers, you will do 90% of your editing in Lightroom / Capture One and not in Photoshop. However, many photographers would hate to let go of Photoshop. Even though a good photo editor like Affinity Photo might be able to replace Photoshop for your needs.
Capture One doesn’t have a history panel
The history panel in Lightroom is handy for going back to a specific point in your editing process and redo everything from there. Capture One lets you undo edits, of course, but you cannot see a list of the latest edits so that you can go back to a specific point. Capture One lets you reset every tool separately or reset all the edits you have done to your photo. It is flexible, but not the same as having a history panel.
No panorama and HDR tools in Capture One.
For landscape photographers, this is a big drawback. Without these tools, you have to use other programs, like Photoshop, which you will lose, if you cancel your LR/PS subscription. The panorama and HDR tools in Lightroom even generate DNG files as the output for the panorama and HDR image instead of large TIFF files.
More Lightroom presets available vs. Capture One Styles
There are more presets available for Lightroom, even though there are great offers for Capture One styles on the market as well. This is, of course, only a drawback if you have a workflow that relies on presets. If you have invested a lot of money in a preset system for Lightroom, this will, of course, hold you back from switching to Capture One. Just remember that you don’t need hundreds of Capture One styles or Lightroom presets. You only need good ones that match your photo editing style and inspirational needs.
Max adjustment strength
Lightroom’s max adjustment strength of most tools is stronger vs. the tools in Capture One. On some occasions, you need to max out the effect of a tool. Here Lightroom has the upper hand, even though Capture One is not much behind. Most of the time, at 100% strength, any effect will produce unnatural looking results. So this is definitely not a big issue.
Lightroom is a bit easier to learn than Capture One – if you are a beginner
If you are looking for your first RAW processor, Lightroom is easier to learn compared to Capture One. Capture One is flexible and targeted for professional photographers, who want control of every aspect of the post-processing workflow. Therefore it is also a bit more difficult to learn from scratch, but not by much. More learning material and resources are available for Lightroom vs. for Capture One.
Why you would want to switch to Capture One
Capture One has layers
You can use layers in Capture One but not in Lightroom. In Lightroom, you are limited to the adjustment points that separate the different local adjustments you make with brushes and gradient tools. Once you have created a small number of local adjustment points in Lightroom, editing starts to get slower and lag when you use the brush tool. Working with layers and local adjustments in Capture One is a different league altogether. You can apply almost every adjustment you would want to layers, instead of being confined to changing only basic adjustments in Lightroom. Many photographers have, over the years, pointed out layers to be a much needed and lacking feature in Lightroom. It is also much easier to tone down the adjustments by changing the opacity of the layer with the local adjustments or toggling it on/off. This is one of the areas where Capture One is far better than Lightroom.
Capture One Styles are more flexible than Lightroom presets
Using styles in Capture One is also more flexible vs. Presets in Lightroom. Because of the possibility to add styles to layers in Capture One and the ability to stack multiple styles, you will find more ways to use styles in Capture One than you can for presets in Lightroom. With layers, you can lower the opacity of applied styles, limit the effect by using layer masks. This opens up for a whole new level of creativity when it comes to using presets and styles.
Capture One’s interface is more flexible
Capture One’s interface is generally better than Lightroom for advanced photographers. The customizable keyboard shortcuts let you create the shortcuts that fit your particular workflow. You can even mimic the shortcuts from Lightroom if you want to make the transition easier. You can customize the layout of Capture One to your needs. You can add or remove panels to all tabs in Capture One. As you can see further up in the article, you can split up the curves adjustment tool into three and place them on the tab where you usually want to adjust these settings.
Spot healing tool generally works better in Capture One
Spot healing works better in Capture One. The first thing you will notice when using spot healing for larger areas is that Capture One doesn’t have the same lag and delay as you experience in Lightroom. You will also appreciate that the spot healing points don’t overlap as they do in Lightroom, where it can be challenging to grab the right healing point if you want to modify it. One of the most important points about spot healing is that the result looks better in Capture One.
Save default values for anything
Capture One allows you to save default values for almost anything. Not only that, you can save default values for each tool in the interface for each camera you use. This can be a big time saver when using different cameras.
Capture One is generally faster
Performance is generally better in Capture One. You won’t sit waiting in front of your computer waiting for Capture One to load the next image (if you chose the right preview size under preferences). In terms of performance and speed comparing Capture One vs. Lightroom, you will find that Lightroom is the slower one. It often lags when browsing images, which is not the case with Capture One. Also, during preview generation after importing photos, you will likely notice that Capture One is considerably faster.
One of the really awesome things in Capture One is its focus mask feature. When you enable the focus mask, a mask overlay will appear, showing which areas are in focus. This saves you a wast amount of time switching between photos to find out which one is the sharpest. The focus mask even works while browsing in grid mode or comparing images side by side, showing a focus mask for each image.
Another cool feature is the Loupe tool, which allows you to magnify the area you hover over to 100%. The Loupe tool also works from grid view, in browser mode, or on a single image. It saves you a lot of time, of opening an image, zooming into 100% to check its sharpness or details, and then closing it again. With the Loupe tool, you can just hover over the area you want to see at 100%.
Output to multiple file-types at the same time
Process recipes is another Capture One feature for handling exporting / output processing tasks that wins over Lightroom’s export feature. With process recipes, you can set up Capture One export to multiple formats at the same time. If you want to export your images for social media use, a website, print, and export the original file in the same process, you only have to check these different formats. You need to set them up for the first time and save them as a process recipe, of course, but after that, it is incredibly flexible and time-saving. An additional benefit of the export feature is better output sharpening option, outputting to different locations, and even recipe-proofing the output result at 100% before pressing the Process button. When comparing Capture One vs. Lightroom for output or export options Capture One is again ahead of Lightroom.
Default image quality is a little bit better
Straight from the camera, your images will look slightly better in Capture One, with a little more saturation, and with more vivid colors. It is only a tiny bit, but you will feel like a better photographer. However, this might not be your preferred starting point for editing your photos.
Is Capture One Better Than Lightroom?
In short, YES. The long answer is that it probably depends on how you prefer to edit your photos. Lightroom is simpler vs. Capture One, where you get more control of almost every aspect of the photo editing workflow. So Capture One is likely a better choice for advanced and professional users, but it is also a bit more expensive.
As you can see, it’s pretty tough deciding between Capture One vs. Lightroom. In a lot of scenarios Capture One feels more superior than Lightroom when it comes to color editing, tethering and exporting images. However, in most cases, you might still need the use of Photoshop after that and then the Lightroom + Photoshop plan might seem more lucrative.
Lightroom offers a lot more plugins and third-party software add-ons, presets, HDR merging and panorama stitching all of which are still poorly presented or non-existent in Capture One.
On the other hand, Capture One feels more modern in a way, customizable, more color oriented, with advanced exporting options which allow you to export different sizes and resolutions at the same time and even an application for your mobile which allows you to rate images, remote control your camera and what-not.
In any case, both software products are the best at what they do and at the end of the day, the best one is the one you feel more comfortable using.